PTIJ: Why do we make a Lulav holder? [closed]Parashat Tazria+HachodeshPesach/PassoverWhat is the traditional...
What does it mean to describe someone as a butt steak?
How to prevent "they're falling in love" trope
Why "Having chlorophyll without photosynthesis is actually very dangerous" and "like living with a bomb"?
Will google still index a page if I use a $_SESSION variable?
Is it unprofessional to ask if a job posting on GlassDoor is real?
Theorems that impeded progress
How to take photos in burst mode, without vibration?
How could indestructible materials be used in power generation?
How much of data wrangling is a data scientist's job?
Why is the 'in' operator throwing an error with a string literal instead of logging false?
What's the point of deactivating Num Lock on login screens?
Would Slavery Reparations be considered Bills of Attainder and hence Illegal?
Were any external disk drives stacked vertically?
Infinite Abelian subgroup of infinite non Abelian group example
Facing a paradox: Earnshaw's theorem in one dimension
Can a rocket refuel on Mars from water?
Stopping power of mountain vs road bike
Watching something be written to a file live with tail
How can I tell someone that I want to be his or her friend?
How is it possible to have an ability score that is less than 3?
Is the Joker left-handed?
Can I ask the recruiters in my resume to put the reason why I am rejected?
What is the word for reserving something for yourself before others do?
Blender 2.8 I can't see vertices, edges or faces in edit mode
PTIJ: Why do we make a Lulav holder? [closed]
Parashat Tazria+HachodeshPesach/PassoverWhat is the traditional Jewish name for this dish?PtIJ: why a twisted 6PTIJ: Why does Hashem have an onionPTIJ: OTD DocumentariesPTIJ: How to make a palace out of peoplePTIJ: Why did the Torah forbid itself?PTIJ: Why can't I eat anything?PTIJ: Why do we blow Shofar on Rosh Hashana and use a Lulav on Sukkos?
The Gemara says:
אין עושין מצות חבילות חבילות
One does not make mitzvot into bundles.
But I've seen lots of people do just that: They put the four species into a bundle.
ואם תומר, and if you'll say:
The issue is making a Mitzva into a bundle, not putting the Mitzvah into a bundle.
You can't say that since the bundle is made from Lulav leaves. So we quite literally made a Mitzvah into a bundle.
Oh, and there are some who only make a bundle out of the Lulav, without even making a basket.
That should definitely be an issue.
This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.
purim-torah-in-jest
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
closed as off-topic by msh210♦ Mar 23 at 22:27
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Purim Torah questions are on-topic only once a year, and will be closed after Purim. For details, see: Purim Torah policy" – msh210
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
|
show 12 more comments
The Gemara says:
אין עושין מצות חבילות חבילות
One does not make mitzvot into bundles.
But I've seen lots of people do just that: They put the four species into a bundle.
ואם תומר, and if you'll say:
The issue is making a Mitzva into a bundle, not putting the Mitzvah into a bundle.
You can't say that since the bundle is made from Lulav leaves. So we quite literally made a Mitzvah into a bundle.
Oh, and there are some who only make a bundle out of the Lulav, without even making a basket.
That should definitely be an issue.
This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.
purim-torah-in-jest
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
closed as off-topic by msh210♦ Mar 23 at 22:27
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Purim Torah questions are on-topic only once a year, and will be closed after Purim. For details, see: Purim Torah policy" – msh210
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
2
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
1
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29
|
show 12 more comments
The Gemara says:
אין עושין מצות חבילות חבילות
One does not make mitzvot into bundles.
But I've seen lots of people do just that: They put the four species into a bundle.
ואם תומר, and if you'll say:
The issue is making a Mitzva into a bundle, not putting the Mitzvah into a bundle.
You can't say that since the bundle is made from Lulav leaves. So we quite literally made a Mitzvah into a bundle.
Oh, and there are some who only make a bundle out of the Lulav, without even making a basket.
That should definitely be an issue.
This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.
purim-torah-in-jest
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
The Gemara says:
אין עושין מצות חבילות חבילות
One does not make mitzvot into bundles.
But I've seen lots of people do just that: They put the four species into a bundle.
ואם תומר, and if you'll say:
The issue is making a Mitzva into a bundle, not putting the Mitzvah into a bundle.
You can't say that since the bundle is made from Lulav leaves. So we quite literally made a Mitzvah into a bundle.
Oh, and there are some who only make a bundle out of the Lulav, without even making a basket.
That should definitely be an issue.
This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.
purim-torah-in-jest
purim-torah-in-jest
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
asked Mar 18 at 21:36
LeitzLeitz
926212
926212
closed as off-topic by msh210♦ Mar 23 at 22:27
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Purim Torah questions are on-topic only once a year, and will be closed after Purim. For details, see: Purim Torah policy" – msh210
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
closed as off-topic by msh210♦ Mar 23 at 22:27
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Purim Torah questions are on-topic only once a year, and will be closed after Purim. For details, see: Purim Torah policy" – msh210
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
2
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
1
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29
|
show 12 more comments
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
2
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
1
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
2
2
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
1
1
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29
|
show 12 more comments
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
The proper way to punctuate it is
אין עושין מצוות חבילות - חבילות
One should not make bundles of mitzvos into bundles
So, taking just one mitzvah, like the lulav, and making it into a bundle is perfectly fine. If you were to take your whole lulav-bundle and wrap a lulav with that, using a bundle of mitzvos to bundle, that would be a problem.
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
add a comment |
The Gemara didn't need to repeat the word חבילות must be אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות and the Gemara is teaching you that if you are bundling them many times it is mutar.
So if you don't have a basket you are fine because you bundle it several times and the problem is only if you have one basket.
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
add a comment |
In Aramaic the word אין means yes. The PTIJ explanation of this is Yes we make Mitzvas into bundles.
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The proper way to punctuate it is
אין עושין מצוות חבילות - חבילות
One should not make bundles of mitzvos into bundles
So, taking just one mitzvah, like the lulav, and making it into a bundle is perfectly fine. If you were to take your whole lulav-bundle and wrap a lulav with that, using a bundle of mitzvos to bundle, that would be a problem.
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
add a comment |
The proper way to punctuate it is
אין עושין מצוות חבילות - חבילות
One should not make bundles of mitzvos into bundles
So, taking just one mitzvah, like the lulav, and making it into a bundle is perfectly fine. If you were to take your whole lulav-bundle and wrap a lulav with that, using a bundle of mitzvos to bundle, that would be a problem.
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
add a comment |
The proper way to punctuate it is
אין עושין מצוות חבילות - חבילות
One should not make bundles of mitzvos into bundles
So, taking just one mitzvah, like the lulav, and making it into a bundle is perfectly fine. If you were to take your whole lulav-bundle and wrap a lulav with that, using a bundle of mitzvos to bundle, that would be a problem.
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
The proper way to punctuate it is
אין עושין מצוות חבילות - חבילות
One should not make bundles of mitzvos into bundles
So, taking just one mitzvah, like the lulav, and making it into a bundle is perfectly fine. If you were to take your whole lulav-bundle and wrap a lulav with that, using a bundle of mitzvos to bundle, that would be a problem.
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
answered Mar 19 at 3:54
Y e zY e z
46.4k375209
46.4k375209
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
add a comment |
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
+1. in this case you are wrapping a bundle of mitzvos-daled minim- with a mitzvah-lulav leaf-
– Asher
Mar 19 at 3:57
add a comment |
The Gemara didn't need to repeat the word חבילות must be אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות and the Gemara is teaching you that if you are bundling them many times it is mutar.
So if you don't have a basket you are fine because you bundle it several times and the problem is only if you have one basket.
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
add a comment |
The Gemara didn't need to repeat the word חבילות must be אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות and the Gemara is teaching you that if you are bundling them many times it is mutar.
So if you don't have a basket you are fine because you bundle it several times and the problem is only if you have one basket.
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
add a comment |
The Gemara didn't need to repeat the word חבילות must be אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות and the Gemara is teaching you that if you are bundling them many times it is mutar.
So if you don't have a basket you are fine because you bundle it several times and the problem is only if you have one basket.
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
The Gemara didn't need to repeat the word חבילות must be אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות and the Gemara is teaching you that if you are bundling them many times it is mutar.
So if you don't have a basket you are fine because you bundle it several times and the problem is only if you have one basket.
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
edited Mar 19 at 4:16
Alex
23.3k156133
23.3k156133
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
answered Mar 19 at 3:48
AsherAsher
1819
1819
add a comment |
add a comment |
In Aramaic the word אין means yes. The PTIJ explanation of this is Yes we make Mitzvas into bundles.
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
add a comment |
In Aramaic the word אין means yes. The PTIJ explanation of this is Yes we make Mitzvas into bundles.
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
add a comment |
In Aramaic the word אין means yes. The PTIJ explanation of this is Yes we make Mitzvas into bundles.
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
In Aramaic the word אין means yes. The PTIJ explanation of this is Yes we make Mitzvas into bundles.
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
answered Mar 19 at 0:32
Gershon GoldGershon Gold
111k8180427
111k8180427
add a comment |
add a comment |
VTC as not Purim Torah
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:45
@DoubleAA Ummm... You think that this is a real question?
– Leitz
Mar 18 at 21:45
2
If I removed the disclaimer, would you be able to tell it wasn't?
– Double AA♦
Mar 18 at 21:50
Yes because he is making a pun of חבילות חבילות @DoubleAA
– Dr. Shmuel
Mar 18 at 21:51
1
@DoubleAA From the way that he addresses the serious question, answering it by posing the ridiculous Purim Torah interpretation (turning the lulav into a bundle), it's clear he means it as PTIJ. Consider judaism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1990, whose guidelines the OP is definitely following.
– DonielF
Mar 18 at 22:29