What was so special about The Piano that Ada was willing to do anything to have it?In Fight Club is Marla...

They call me Inspector Morse

How do you like my writing?

Space in array system equations

Solving "Resistance between two nodes on a grid" problem in Mathematica

"One can do his homework in the library"

BitNot does not flip bits in the way I expected

How does airport security verify that you can carry a battery bank over 100 Wh?

Why does the negative sign arise in this thermodynamic relation?

Why doesn't this Google Translate ad use the word "Translation" instead of "Translate"?

Accountant/ lawyer will not return my call

Does "variables should live in the smallest scope as possible" include the case "variables should not exist if possible"?

Unreachable code, but reachable with exception

If the Captain's screens are out, does he switch seats with the co-pilot?

What are some noteworthy "mic-drop" moments in math?

Best approach to update all entries in a list that is paginated?

What to do when during a meeting client people start to fight (even physically) with each others?

What is the likely impact of grounding an entire aircraft series?

Subset counting for even numbers

Do Bugbears' arms literally get longer when it's their turn?

How much attack damage does the AC boost from a shield prevent on average?

Good for you! in Russian

How do I locate a classical quotation?

Who deserves to be first and second author? PhD student who collected data, research associate who wrote the paper or supervisor?

Why the color red for the Republican Party



What was so special about The Piano that Ada was willing to do anything to have it?


In Fight Club is Marla Singer a second figment of Jack's imagination?What was the special reason?What's the point of the overly complex abduction?Why is Jack Bauer always right, above the law and free to do what he desires, but no one else is?Did Gordo have anything to do with Simon's firm finding out that Danny was framed?How come Sherlock still remembers how to play the violin?Do the powers other characters have in Legion represent anything?Do Wonder Woman's bracelets have special powers?Was there something special about Ivan's bird?Does the act of Bobby rescuing his friends affect whether or not Joyce's chains pull her down?













8















In the movie The Piano, Ada is a mute, who likes to play the piano. When she's married off to Stewart, she insist on taking the piano with her.



Baines, Stewart's friend, buys the Piano from him against her will. When Baines offers up the Piano to Ada in exchange for sexual favors, she's willing to indulge his every request.



Why was the Piano so important to Ada that she was willing to do anything to get it back?










share|improve this question



























    8















    In the movie The Piano, Ada is a mute, who likes to play the piano. When she's married off to Stewart, she insist on taking the piano with her.



    Baines, Stewart's friend, buys the Piano from him against her will. When Baines offers up the Piano to Ada in exchange for sexual favors, she's willing to indulge his every request.



    Why was the Piano so important to Ada that she was willing to do anything to get it back?










    share|improve this question

























      8












      8








      8


      0






      In the movie The Piano, Ada is a mute, who likes to play the piano. When she's married off to Stewart, she insist on taking the piano with her.



      Baines, Stewart's friend, buys the Piano from him against her will. When Baines offers up the Piano to Ada in exchange for sexual favors, she's willing to indulge his every request.



      Why was the Piano so important to Ada that she was willing to do anything to get it back?










      share|improve this question














      In the movie The Piano, Ada is a mute, who likes to play the piano. When she's married off to Stewart, she insist on taking the piano with her.



      Baines, Stewart's friend, buys the Piano from him against her will. When Baines offers up the Piano to Ada in exchange for sexual favors, she's willing to indulge his every request.



      Why was the Piano so important to Ada that she was willing to do anything to get it back?







      plot-explanation the-piano






      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question











      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question










      asked Mar 9 at 14:01









      KharoBangdoKharoBangdo

      4,904124486




      4,904124486






















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          8














          Jane Campion, from The Independent (article by Quentin Curtis, October 1993):




          She is sympathetically out of step with the rest of the world: too extreme, too purist, too wild - particularly in Victorian times - to be understood. She has too high motives, and the world will always disappoint her. The piano enables her to have a voice, becoming almost indistinguishable from herself. Their fates are linked. And because she doesn't speak, her intimacy with people becomes more instinctive and physical. Which takes us into the area that the film is exploring about eroticism and fetishism.




          And on the relationship between Baines and Ada:




          'He never forces her to do anything,' Campion says. 'He may start by pushing her, but he finds it important for her to come to him willingly. He wants to be loved: which is what separates him from a psychopath, who wouldn't believe that anybody could love him.'




          Ada, a mute widow in Victorian times, is sold into a marriage in a foreign country and can only express herself through her piano. When her piano is taken away from her - against her will - she wants to get it back. She has nothing, except for her piano and her daughter. For sure, it seems like Baines exploits her, but as Campion notes, he loves her and she is actually willing.





          On why that piano specifically (source is the 4thd draft of the script).



          1) It's a special piano



          Ada developed a special relationship to her piano. That's not unusual, as Christian Jarrett writes in the psychologist:




          As our lives unfold, our things embody our sense of self-hood and identity still further, becoming external receptacles for our memories, relationships and travels.




          Probably even more so for Ada, since she is so dependent on it. She needs it to express herself, so it's basically her voice. And a longstanding "relationship" (her husband died, her daughter is only 10 years old) - in scene 35, Stewart says he has it in a letter that she has been playing piano since she was 5 or 6.



          From Scene 9:




          Her daughter is on all fours evidently being sick. But ADA's attention
          is diverted to the seamen who are staggering through the waves with a
          huge piano shaped box. They put it down as soon as they get to 5hore
          but ADA makes gestures that they must immediately bring it to higher
          safer ground. The piano placed to her satisfaction she hovers near it,
          one hand in constant touch of it while her daughter grips her free
          hand.




          Or in scene 36 (Stewart tells her about the deal):



          Ada "finger signs, her face furious." and then Flora translates




          She says it's her piano, and she won't have him touch it. He's an oaf, he can't read, he's ignorant.




          and then




          ADA's breathing becomes heavy with anger, she writes Curiously on her
          pad.



          NO! NO! THE PIANO IS MINE! IT'S MINE!




          It's also a special piano in itself, see scene 43 where the blind man, who should tune it, tells Baines:




          Ah, a Broadbent. A fine instrument. I've not come across one here, or in the Islands where I have tuned some 200. Yes, they like their pianos there.




          2) The only piano she could get



          Ada is mute, in a foreign country where she knows no one (except for her daughter), including her husband. Even though her piano would be the easiest to get - it's already hers, you only need to pay for transport, the transport crew is already there - but still Stewart refuses (read scene 16). When Ada plays the kitchen table like it was a piano, Stewart notes (scene 34):




          I knew she was mute, but now I'm thinking it's more than that. I'm wondering if she's not brain affected.




          It's clear that he doesn't care (and trades it to Baines without consulting her, scene 35). How would she have gotten another piano? Would Stewart have given her money, is there a town in 1850s New Zealand where she, together with her 10-year-old translator, could buy one and then transport it to their house? If Stewart had been willing, all could have been much easier. But her husband does not care.



          3) The piano easiest to get



          This is from a different angle - the piano is still the closest and easiest one to get. She knows who has it (Baines) and is even forced to stay with him to teach him (Stewart at the end of scene 36: "You will teach him. I shall see to that!"). And Baines loves her (unlike her husband!). It looks like exploitation at first, but in a way Ada turns the tables and uses it to her advantage and to exert power over him. She can get back a piano, her piano, by herself.



          Regarding the way she gets it back, the sexual favors, allow me a short digression to illustrate the point. When talking about The Wolf of Wallstreet, Margot Robbie said (Robbie Collin, The Daily Telegraph, 2014 from the Business Insider):




          The whole point of Naomi is that her body is her only form of currency in this world. So when Marty was trying to help me out, and said in the scene where she seduces Jordan perhaps I could have a robe on, I said she wouldn't. She has to be naked. She's laying her cards on the table.




          That's even more the case for Ada - that's what she can offer a man who is in love with her: Intimacy.






          share|improve this answer





















          • 2





            But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

            – zrajm
            Mar 10 at 0:11











          • She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

            – user207421
            Mar 10 at 2:56








          • 1





            From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

            – Anne Daunted
            2 days ago











          • @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

            – Robert Harvey
            2 days ago



















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes








          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes









          8














          Jane Campion, from The Independent (article by Quentin Curtis, October 1993):




          She is sympathetically out of step with the rest of the world: too extreme, too purist, too wild - particularly in Victorian times - to be understood. She has too high motives, and the world will always disappoint her. The piano enables her to have a voice, becoming almost indistinguishable from herself. Their fates are linked. And because she doesn't speak, her intimacy with people becomes more instinctive and physical. Which takes us into the area that the film is exploring about eroticism and fetishism.




          And on the relationship between Baines and Ada:




          'He never forces her to do anything,' Campion says. 'He may start by pushing her, but he finds it important for her to come to him willingly. He wants to be loved: which is what separates him from a psychopath, who wouldn't believe that anybody could love him.'




          Ada, a mute widow in Victorian times, is sold into a marriage in a foreign country and can only express herself through her piano. When her piano is taken away from her - against her will - she wants to get it back. She has nothing, except for her piano and her daughter. For sure, it seems like Baines exploits her, but as Campion notes, he loves her and she is actually willing.





          On why that piano specifically (source is the 4thd draft of the script).



          1) It's a special piano



          Ada developed a special relationship to her piano. That's not unusual, as Christian Jarrett writes in the psychologist:




          As our lives unfold, our things embody our sense of self-hood and identity still further, becoming external receptacles for our memories, relationships and travels.




          Probably even more so for Ada, since she is so dependent on it. She needs it to express herself, so it's basically her voice. And a longstanding "relationship" (her husband died, her daughter is only 10 years old) - in scene 35, Stewart says he has it in a letter that she has been playing piano since she was 5 or 6.



          From Scene 9:




          Her daughter is on all fours evidently being sick. But ADA's attention
          is diverted to the seamen who are staggering through the waves with a
          huge piano shaped box. They put it down as soon as they get to 5hore
          but ADA makes gestures that they must immediately bring it to higher
          safer ground. The piano placed to her satisfaction she hovers near it,
          one hand in constant touch of it while her daughter grips her free
          hand.




          Or in scene 36 (Stewart tells her about the deal):



          Ada "finger signs, her face furious." and then Flora translates




          She says it's her piano, and she won't have him touch it. He's an oaf, he can't read, he's ignorant.




          and then




          ADA's breathing becomes heavy with anger, she writes Curiously on her
          pad.



          NO! NO! THE PIANO IS MINE! IT'S MINE!




          It's also a special piano in itself, see scene 43 where the blind man, who should tune it, tells Baines:




          Ah, a Broadbent. A fine instrument. I've not come across one here, or in the Islands where I have tuned some 200. Yes, they like their pianos there.




          2) The only piano she could get



          Ada is mute, in a foreign country where she knows no one (except for her daughter), including her husband. Even though her piano would be the easiest to get - it's already hers, you only need to pay for transport, the transport crew is already there - but still Stewart refuses (read scene 16). When Ada plays the kitchen table like it was a piano, Stewart notes (scene 34):




          I knew she was mute, but now I'm thinking it's more than that. I'm wondering if she's not brain affected.




          It's clear that he doesn't care (and trades it to Baines without consulting her, scene 35). How would she have gotten another piano? Would Stewart have given her money, is there a town in 1850s New Zealand where she, together with her 10-year-old translator, could buy one and then transport it to their house? If Stewart had been willing, all could have been much easier. But her husband does not care.



          3) The piano easiest to get



          This is from a different angle - the piano is still the closest and easiest one to get. She knows who has it (Baines) and is even forced to stay with him to teach him (Stewart at the end of scene 36: "You will teach him. I shall see to that!"). And Baines loves her (unlike her husband!). It looks like exploitation at first, but in a way Ada turns the tables and uses it to her advantage and to exert power over him. She can get back a piano, her piano, by herself.



          Regarding the way she gets it back, the sexual favors, allow me a short digression to illustrate the point. When talking about The Wolf of Wallstreet, Margot Robbie said (Robbie Collin, The Daily Telegraph, 2014 from the Business Insider):




          The whole point of Naomi is that her body is her only form of currency in this world. So when Marty was trying to help me out, and said in the scene where she seduces Jordan perhaps I could have a robe on, I said she wouldn't. She has to be naked. She's laying her cards on the table.




          That's even more the case for Ada - that's what she can offer a man who is in love with her: Intimacy.






          share|improve this answer





















          • 2





            But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

            – zrajm
            Mar 10 at 0:11











          • She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

            – user207421
            Mar 10 at 2:56








          • 1





            From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

            – Anne Daunted
            2 days ago











          • @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

            – Robert Harvey
            2 days ago
















          8














          Jane Campion, from The Independent (article by Quentin Curtis, October 1993):




          She is sympathetically out of step with the rest of the world: too extreme, too purist, too wild - particularly in Victorian times - to be understood. She has too high motives, and the world will always disappoint her. The piano enables her to have a voice, becoming almost indistinguishable from herself. Their fates are linked. And because she doesn't speak, her intimacy with people becomes more instinctive and physical. Which takes us into the area that the film is exploring about eroticism and fetishism.




          And on the relationship between Baines and Ada:




          'He never forces her to do anything,' Campion says. 'He may start by pushing her, but he finds it important for her to come to him willingly. He wants to be loved: which is what separates him from a psychopath, who wouldn't believe that anybody could love him.'




          Ada, a mute widow in Victorian times, is sold into a marriage in a foreign country and can only express herself through her piano. When her piano is taken away from her - against her will - she wants to get it back. She has nothing, except for her piano and her daughter. For sure, it seems like Baines exploits her, but as Campion notes, he loves her and she is actually willing.





          On why that piano specifically (source is the 4thd draft of the script).



          1) It's a special piano



          Ada developed a special relationship to her piano. That's not unusual, as Christian Jarrett writes in the psychologist:




          As our lives unfold, our things embody our sense of self-hood and identity still further, becoming external receptacles for our memories, relationships and travels.




          Probably even more so for Ada, since she is so dependent on it. She needs it to express herself, so it's basically her voice. And a longstanding "relationship" (her husband died, her daughter is only 10 years old) - in scene 35, Stewart says he has it in a letter that she has been playing piano since she was 5 or 6.



          From Scene 9:




          Her daughter is on all fours evidently being sick. But ADA's attention
          is diverted to the seamen who are staggering through the waves with a
          huge piano shaped box. They put it down as soon as they get to 5hore
          but ADA makes gestures that they must immediately bring it to higher
          safer ground. The piano placed to her satisfaction she hovers near it,
          one hand in constant touch of it while her daughter grips her free
          hand.




          Or in scene 36 (Stewart tells her about the deal):



          Ada "finger signs, her face furious." and then Flora translates




          She says it's her piano, and she won't have him touch it. He's an oaf, he can't read, he's ignorant.




          and then




          ADA's breathing becomes heavy with anger, she writes Curiously on her
          pad.



          NO! NO! THE PIANO IS MINE! IT'S MINE!




          It's also a special piano in itself, see scene 43 where the blind man, who should tune it, tells Baines:




          Ah, a Broadbent. A fine instrument. I've not come across one here, or in the Islands where I have tuned some 200. Yes, they like their pianos there.




          2) The only piano she could get



          Ada is mute, in a foreign country where she knows no one (except for her daughter), including her husband. Even though her piano would be the easiest to get - it's already hers, you only need to pay for transport, the transport crew is already there - but still Stewart refuses (read scene 16). When Ada plays the kitchen table like it was a piano, Stewart notes (scene 34):




          I knew she was mute, but now I'm thinking it's more than that. I'm wondering if she's not brain affected.




          It's clear that he doesn't care (and trades it to Baines without consulting her, scene 35). How would she have gotten another piano? Would Stewart have given her money, is there a town in 1850s New Zealand where she, together with her 10-year-old translator, could buy one and then transport it to their house? If Stewart had been willing, all could have been much easier. But her husband does not care.



          3) The piano easiest to get



          This is from a different angle - the piano is still the closest and easiest one to get. She knows who has it (Baines) and is even forced to stay with him to teach him (Stewart at the end of scene 36: "You will teach him. I shall see to that!"). And Baines loves her (unlike her husband!). It looks like exploitation at first, but in a way Ada turns the tables and uses it to her advantage and to exert power over him. She can get back a piano, her piano, by herself.



          Regarding the way she gets it back, the sexual favors, allow me a short digression to illustrate the point. When talking about The Wolf of Wallstreet, Margot Robbie said (Robbie Collin, The Daily Telegraph, 2014 from the Business Insider):




          The whole point of Naomi is that her body is her only form of currency in this world. So when Marty was trying to help me out, and said in the scene where she seduces Jordan perhaps I could have a robe on, I said she wouldn't. She has to be naked. She's laying her cards on the table.




          That's even more the case for Ada - that's what she can offer a man who is in love with her: Intimacy.






          share|improve this answer





















          • 2





            But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

            – zrajm
            Mar 10 at 0:11











          • She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

            – user207421
            Mar 10 at 2:56








          • 1





            From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

            – Anne Daunted
            2 days ago











          • @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

            – Robert Harvey
            2 days ago














          8












          8








          8







          Jane Campion, from The Independent (article by Quentin Curtis, October 1993):




          She is sympathetically out of step with the rest of the world: too extreme, too purist, too wild - particularly in Victorian times - to be understood. She has too high motives, and the world will always disappoint her. The piano enables her to have a voice, becoming almost indistinguishable from herself. Their fates are linked. And because she doesn't speak, her intimacy with people becomes more instinctive and physical. Which takes us into the area that the film is exploring about eroticism and fetishism.




          And on the relationship between Baines and Ada:




          'He never forces her to do anything,' Campion says. 'He may start by pushing her, but he finds it important for her to come to him willingly. He wants to be loved: which is what separates him from a psychopath, who wouldn't believe that anybody could love him.'




          Ada, a mute widow in Victorian times, is sold into a marriage in a foreign country and can only express herself through her piano. When her piano is taken away from her - against her will - she wants to get it back. She has nothing, except for her piano and her daughter. For sure, it seems like Baines exploits her, but as Campion notes, he loves her and she is actually willing.





          On why that piano specifically (source is the 4thd draft of the script).



          1) It's a special piano



          Ada developed a special relationship to her piano. That's not unusual, as Christian Jarrett writes in the psychologist:




          As our lives unfold, our things embody our sense of self-hood and identity still further, becoming external receptacles for our memories, relationships and travels.




          Probably even more so for Ada, since she is so dependent on it. She needs it to express herself, so it's basically her voice. And a longstanding "relationship" (her husband died, her daughter is only 10 years old) - in scene 35, Stewart says he has it in a letter that she has been playing piano since she was 5 or 6.



          From Scene 9:




          Her daughter is on all fours evidently being sick. But ADA's attention
          is diverted to the seamen who are staggering through the waves with a
          huge piano shaped box. They put it down as soon as they get to 5hore
          but ADA makes gestures that they must immediately bring it to higher
          safer ground. The piano placed to her satisfaction she hovers near it,
          one hand in constant touch of it while her daughter grips her free
          hand.




          Or in scene 36 (Stewart tells her about the deal):



          Ada "finger signs, her face furious." and then Flora translates




          She says it's her piano, and she won't have him touch it. He's an oaf, he can't read, he's ignorant.




          and then




          ADA's breathing becomes heavy with anger, she writes Curiously on her
          pad.



          NO! NO! THE PIANO IS MINE! IT'S MINE!




          It's also a special piano in itself, see scene 43 where the blind man, who should tune it, tells Baines:




          Ah, a Broadbent. A fine instrument. I've not come across one here, or in the Islands where I have tuned some 200. Yes, they like their pianos there.




          2) The only piano she could get



          Ada is mute, in a foreign country where she knows no one (except for her daughter), including her husband. Even though her piano would be the easiest to get - it's already hers, you only need to pay for transport, the transport crew is already there - but still Stewart refuses (read scene 16). When Ada plays the kitchen table like it was a piano, Stewart notes (scene 34):




          I knew she was mute, but now I'm thinking it's more than that. I'm wondering if she's not brain affected.




          It's clear that he doesn't care (and trades it to Baines without consulting her, scene 35). How would she have gotten another piano? Would Stewart have given her money, is there a town in 1850s New Zealand where she, together with her 10-year-old translator, could buy one and then transport it to their house? If Stewart had been willing, all could have been much easier. But her husband does not care.



          3) The piano easiest to get



          This is from a different angle - the piano is still the closest and easiest one to get. She knows who has it (Baines) and is even forced to stay with him to teach him (Stewart at the end of scene 36: "You will teach him. I shall see to that!"). And Baines loves her (unlike her husband!). It looks like exploitation at first, but in a way Ada turns the tables and uses it to her advantage and to exert power over him. She can get back a piano, her piano, by herself.



          Regarding the way she gets it back, the sexual favors, allow me a short digression to illustrate the point. When talking about The Wolf of Wallstreet, Margot Robbie said (Robbie Collin, The Daily Telegraph, 2014 from the Business Insider):




          The whole point of Naomi is that her body is her only form of currency in this world. So when Marty was trying to help me out, and said in the scene where she seduces Jordan perhaps I could have a robe on, I said she wouldn't. She has to be naked. She's laying her cards on the table.




          That's even more the case for Ada - that's what she can offer a man who is in love with her: Intimacy.






          share|improve this answer















          Jane Campion, from The Independent (article by Quentin Curtis, October 1993):




          She is sympathetically out of step with the rest of the world: too extreme, too purist, too wild - particularly in Victorian times - to be understood. She has too high motives, and the world will always disappoint her. The piano enables her to have a voice, becoming almost indistinguishable from herself. Their fates are linked. And because she doesn't speak, her intimacy with people becomes more instinctive and physical. Which takes us into the area that the film is exploring about eroticism and fetishism.




          And on the relationship between Baines and Ada:




          'He never forces her to do anything,' Campion says. 'He may start by pushing her, but he finds it important for her to come to him willingly. He wants to be loved: which is what separates him from a psychopath, who wouldn't believe that anybody could love him.'




          Ada, a mute widow in Victorian times, is sold into a marriage in a foreign country and can only express herself through her piano. When her piano is taken away from her - against her will - she wants to get it back. She has nothing, except for her piano and her daughter. For sure, it seems like Baines exploits her, but as Campion notes, he loves her and she is actually willing.





          On why that piano specifically (source is the 4thd draft of the script).



          1) It's a special piano



          Ada developed a special relationship to her piano. That's not unusual, as Christian Jarrett writes in the psychologist:




          As our lives unfold, our things embody our sense of self-hood and identity still further, becoming external receptacles for our memories, relationships and travels.




          Probably even more so for Ada, since she is so dependent on it. She needs it to express herself, so it's basically her voice. And a longstanding "relationship" (her husband died, her daughter is only 10 years old) - in scene 35, Stewart says he has it in a letter that she has been playing piano since she was 5 or 6.



          From Scene 9:




          Her daughter is on all fours evidently being sick. But ADA's attention
          is diverted to the seamen who are staggering through the waves with a
          huge piano shaped box. They put it down as soon as they get to 5hore
          but ADA makes gestures that they must immediately bring it to higher
          safer ground. The piano placed to her satisfaction she hovers near it,
          one hand in constant touch of it while her daughter grips her free
          hand.




          Or in scene 36 (Stewart tells her about the deal):



          Ada "finger signs, her face furious." and then Flora translates




          She says it's her piano, and she won't have him touch it. He's an oaf, he can't read, he's ignorant.




          and then




          ADA's breathing becomes heavy with anger, she writes Curiously on her
          pad.



          NO! NO! THE PIANO IS MINE! IT'S MINE!




          It's also a special piano in itself, see scene 43 where the blind man, who should tune it, tells Baines:




          Ah, a Broadbent. A fine instrument. I've not come across one here, or in the Islands where I have tuned some 200. Yes, they like their pianos there.




          2) The only piano she could get



          Ada is mute, in a foreign country where she knows no one (except for her daughter), including her husband. Even though her piano would be the easiest to get - it's already hers, you only need to pay for transport, the transport crew is already there - but still Stewart refuses (read scene 16). When Ada plays the kitchen table like it was a piano, Stewart notes (scene 34):




          I knew she was mute, but now I'm thinking it's more than that. I'm wondering if she's not brain affected.




          It's clear that he doesn't care (and trades it to Baines without consulting her, scene 35). How would she have gotten another piano? Would Stewart have given her money, is there a town in 1850s New Zealand where she, together with her 10-year-old translator, could buy one and then transport it to their house? If Stewart had been willing, all could have been much easier. But her husband does not care.



          3) The piano easiest to get



          This is from a different angle - the piano is still the closest and easiest one to get. She knows who has it (Baines) and is even forced to stay with him to teach him (Stewart at the end of scene 36: "You will teach him. I shall see to that!"). And Baines loves her (unlike her husband!). It looks like exploitation at first, but in a way Ada turns the tables and uses it to her advantage and to exert power over him. She can get back a piano, her piano, by herself.



          Regarding the way she gets it back, the sexual favors, allow me a short digression to illustrate the point. When talking about The Wolf of Wallstreet, Margot Robbie said (Robbie Collin, The Daily Telegraph, 2014 from the Business Insider):




          The whole point of Naomi is that her body is her only form of currency in this world. So when Marty was trying to help me out, and said in the scene where she seduces Jordan perhaps I could have a robe on, I said she wouldn't. She has to be naked. She's laying her cards on the table.




          That's even more the case for Ada - that's what she can offer a man who is in love with her: Intimacy.







          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited 2 days ago

























          answered Mar 9 at 14:38









          Anne DauntedAnne Daunted

          3,95911942




          3,95911942








          • 2





            But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

            – zrajm
            Mar 10 at 0:11











          • She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

            – user207421
            Mar 10 at 2:56








          • 1





            From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

            – Anne Daunted
            2 days ago











          • @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

            – Robert Harvey
            2 days ago














          • 2





            But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

            – zrajm
            Mar 10 at 0:11











          • She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

            – user207421
            Mar 10 at 2:56








          • 1





            From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

            – Anne Daunted
            2 days ago











          • @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

            – Robert Harvey
            2 days ago








          2




          2





          But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

          – zrajm
          Mar 10 at 0:11





          But you haven't answered the question. Why that particular piano?

          – zrajm
          Mar 10 at 0:11













          She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

          – user207421
          Mar 10 at 2:56







          She is not 'sold into a marriage'. There was no such thing in England. She enters into it voluntarily.

          – user207421
          Mar 10 at 2:56






          1




          1





          From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

          – Anne Daunted
          2 days ago





          From the script (4th draft, scene 1): "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met. Soon my daughter and I shall join him in his own country. My husband said my muteness does not bother him. He writes and hark this: God loves dumb creatures, so why not he!"

          – Anne Daunted
          2 days ago













          @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

          – Robert Harvey
          2 days ago





          @zrajm: Why that particular anything?

          – Robert Harvey
          2 days ago



          Popular posts from this blog

          Nidaros erkebispedøme

          Birsay

          Where did Arya get these scars? Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Favourite questions and answers from the 1st quarter of 2019Why did Arya refuse to end it?Has the pronunciation of Arya Stark's name changed?Has Arya forgiven people?Why did Arya Stark lose her vision?Why can Arya still use the faces?Has the Narrow Sea become narrower?Does Arya Stark know how to make poisons outside of the House of Black and White?Why did Nymeria leave Arya?Why did Arya not kill the Lannister soldiers she encountered in the Riverlands?What is the current canonical age of Sansa, Bran and Arya Stark?