How can I safely use “Thalidomide” in my novel while respecting the trademark? The 2019...
Carnot-Caratheodory metric
What can other administrators access on my machine?
Does it makes sense to buy a new cycle to learn riding?
A poker game description that does not feel gimmicky
What is the meaning of Triage in Cybersec world?
Output the Arecibo Message
Spanish for "widget"
Should I use my personal or workplace e-mail when registering to external websites for work purpose?
How to create dashed lines/arrows in Illustrator
How can I create a character who can assume the widest possible range of creature sizes?
Where does the "burst of radiance" from Holy Weapon originate?
Lethal sonic weapons
"What time...?" or "At what time...?" - what is more grammatically correct?
I looked up a future colleague on LinkedIn before I started a job. I told my colleague about it and he seemed surprised. Should I apologize?
CiviEvent: Public link for events of a specific type
It's possible to achieve negative score?
Does duplicating a spell with Wish count as casting that spell?
What is the use of option -o in the useradd command?
Time travel alters history but people keep saying nothing's changed
Should I write numbers in words or as numerals when there are multiple next to each other?
JSON.serialize: is it possible to suppress null values of a map?
What is the best strategy for white in this position?
Geography at the pixel level
In microwave frequencies, do you use a circulator when you need a (near) perfect diode?
How can I safely use “Thalidomide” in my novel while respecting the trademark?
The 2019 Stack Overflow Developer Survey Results Are InCan a plagiarist sue one who plagiarized them?How does one determine how much of a song you can use without paying?Can you make (Negative) references to real people and places in a novel?Can I use a real college in my fiction book?Can I use the real name of TV shows in my novel?How would I give the rights to my novel to my parents?How can I ban someone from publishing my work without my permission?Can I use a scientific theory for my story?Could I use obsolete brand name in fiction bookIs it legal to write a novel about people playing “League of Legends”?
Thalidomide is a tricky one, as I am referring to its disastrous past regarding birth defects; however, Thalidomide is still used as a immunomodulatory drug today - and even though its used under another name, I'm worried about using the trademarked "Thalidomide" in my novel (One I plan to publish).
Although I try my best to avoid trademarks like the plague, I'm not sure how I can write, especially negatively, in regards to this medicine and the disaster while legally protecting my novel and any subsequent revenue.
Although I could create a pseudonym for "Thalidomide", I do not want to go this route - I reference other important historical events in my novels as well and want to stay as realistic as possible. If possible, I would like to use its actual name.
publishing legal trademark
migrated from english.stackexchange.com Mar 21 at 9:43
This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.
|
show 4 more comments
Thalidomide is a tricky one, as I am referring to its disastrous past regarding birth defects; however, Thalidomide is still used as a immunomodulatory drug today - and even though its used under another name, I'm worried about using the trademarked "Thalidomide" in my novel (One I plan to publish).
Although I try my best to avoid trademarks like the plague, I'm not sure how I can write, especially negatively, in regards to this medicine and the disaster while legally protecting my novel and any subsequent revenue.
Although I could create a pseudonym for "Thalidomide", I do not want to go this route - I reference other important historical events in my novels as well and want to stay as realistic as possible. If possible, I would like to use its actual name.
publishing legal trademark
migrated from english.stackexchange.com Mar 21 at 9:43
This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
5
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
1
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
2
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
1
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37
|
show 4 more comments
Thalidomide is a tricky one, as I am referring to its disastrous past regarding birth defects; however, Thalidomide is still used as a immunomodulatory drug today - and even though its used under another name, I'm worried about using the trademarked "Thalidomide" in my novel (One I plan to publish).
Although I try my best to avoid trademarks like the plague, I'm not sure how I can write, especially negatively, in regards to this medicine and the disaster while legally protecting my novel and any subsequent revenue.
Although I could create a pseudonym for "Thalidomide", I do not want to go this route - I reference other important historical events in my novels as well and want to stay as realistic as possible. If possible, I would like to use its actual name.
publishing legal trademark
Thalidomide is a tricky one, as I am referring to its disastrous past regarding birth defects; however, Thalidomide is still used as a immunomodulatory drug today - and even though its used under another name, I'm worried about using the trademarked "Thalidomide" in my novel (One I plan to publish).
Although I try my best to avoid trademarks like the plague, I'm not sure how I can write, especially negatively, in regards to this medicine and the disaster while legally protecting my novel and any subsequent revenue.
Although I could create a pseudonym for "Thalidomide", I do not want to go this route - I reference other important historical events in my novels as well and want to stay as realistic as possible. If possible, I would like to use its actual name.
publishing legal trademark
publishing legal trademark
edited Mar 21 at 15:52
Cyn
17.8k13883
17.8k13883
asked Mar 20 at 22:55
Margaret BeltMargaret Belt
33129
33129
migrated from english.stackexchange.com Mar 21 at 9:43
This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.
migrated from english.stackexchange.com Mar 21 at 9:43
This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
5
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
1
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
2
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
1
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37
|
show 4 more comments
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
5
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
1
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
2
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
1
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
5
5
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
1
1
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
2
2
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
1
1
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37
|
show 4 more comments
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
Here is the entry for thalidomide in Merriam-Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1983):
thalidomide n {phthalic acid + -id- (fr. imide) + -o- + imide} (1962) : a sedative and hypnotic drug C13H10N2O4 that has been the cause of malformation of infants born to mothers using it during pregnancy
What this entry means is that thalidomide is a generic name for a chemical compound—like aspirin. It isn't a proper name and therefore should not be capitalized.
According to the Wikipedia article on thalidomide, the drug was sold under the following trade names:
Contergan, Thalomid, Immunoprin, Talidex, Talizer, Neurosedyn, Distaval and many others
But if you use the generic term thalidomide, you aren't pointing to any specific brand sold during the 1950s (or later) and, again, you shouldn't capitalize the word.
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
add a comment |
The other answers correctly point out that "thalidomide" is a generic drug and is not trademarked. But I'd like to answer the more general question, which is if/how you can refer to a trademark in a work of fiction.
In a website article, Using Trademarks in Fiction, the author describes 3 issues to consider: “product disparagement,” “trademark dilution” and “trademark tarnishment.”
Product disparagement would be the main issue in your work. Technically it's only a problem if your claims are false, but we know that large companies will bring suit anyway if they feel the need. The costs for them in a garbage suit are few but they can control the press and bankrupt the writer. In the US, it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you can pay your lawyers.
In another web article, Can I Mention Brand Name Products in My Fiction?, the author focuses on 4 issues: "trademark infringement," "trademark dilution," "trademark tarnishment,"and "defamation."
Here, we also have recommendations of an abundance of caution. Big companies can be really touchy.
For example, the director Danny Boyle, told the press that he caused
Mercedes Benz logos to be digitally removed from cars in his film Slum
Dog Millionaire when the manufacturer objected to the depiction of its
cars in Bombay slum settings.
Makers of movies and TV shows generally are a lot more careful than book publishers, because of the wider audiences and more obvious references.
I have not found legal references for what to do when a product is widely acknowledged as having caused harm. Certainly it is okay to talk about (or even show explicitly) the dangers of cigarettes or lead. These aren't trademarks but they both have powerful lobbyists and industry groups. Remember how the beef industry went after Oprah for talking about mad cow disease on her show in 1996? She ultimately won, but only after a lot of her time and money.
So it depends. If all you're doing is mentioning that a character has a disability caused by thalidomide, even if it were a trademarked product, you're probably fine, as it is well-documented that these cases happened.
add a comment |
Thalidomide is the generic form of the brand-name drug Thalomid. I would think no one owns a trademark on a generic name. If you are taking thalidomide to treat XYZ, the most common side effects are: … is an example of a name that is geneticized but if the sentence reads; If you are taking Thalomid … then you would be using the brands name.
add a comment |
If you have a character who has a birth defect caused by thalidomide, just use the term. Thalidomide child or thalidomide baby were how this defect was called.
When I was in university, one of the girls in our dorm announced that her younger sister would be joining her. She warned us of two things: Susan was a thalidomide child and DO NOT help her.
Susan moved into the dorm and she was a tough minded girl. In her case, her defect was that her arms were extremely short. Carrying books was difficult for her, but we had been instructed on how not to drive her nuts.
One afternoon, I saw Susan by the elevator of the Humanities building and she had dropped her books. I asked her if she would like some help - an important lesson in respect - and she agreed it would be faster if I helped, so let me pick up a few of her books and give them to her.
Susan once told me that the doctor who prescribed the thalidomide to her mother apologized to her.
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "166"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f43844%2fhow-can-i-safely-use-thalidomide-in-my-novel-while-respecting-the-trademark%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Here is the entry for thalidomide in Merriam-Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1983):
thalidomide n {phthalic acid + -id- (fr. imide) + -o- + imide} (1962) : a sedative and hypnotic drug C13H10N2O4 that has been the cause of malformation of infants born to mothers using it during pregnancy
What this entry means is that thalidomide is a generic name for a chemical compound—like aspirin. It isn't a proper name and therefore should not be capitalized.
According to the Wikipedia article on thalidomide, the drug was sold under the following trade names:
Contergan, Thalomid, Immunoprin, Talidex, Talizer, Neurosedyn, Distaval and many others
But if you use the generic term thalidomide, you aren't pointing to any specific brand sold during the 1950s (or later) and, again, you shouldn't capitalize the word.
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
add a comment |
Here is the entry for thalidomide in Merriam-Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1983):
thalidomide n {phthalic acid + -id- (fr. imide) + -o- + imide} (1962) : a sedative and hypnotic drug C13H10N2O4 that has been the cause of malformation of infants born to mothers using it during pregnancy
What this entry means is that thalidomide is a generic name for a chemical compound—like aspirin. It isn't a proper name and therefore should not be capitalized.
According to the Wikipedia article on thalidomide, the drug was sold under the following trade names:
Contergan, Thalomid, Immunoprin, Talidex, Talizer, Neurosedyn, Distaval and many others
But if you use the generic term thalidomide, you aren't pointing to any specific brand sold during the 1950s (or later) and, again, you shouldn't capitalize the word.
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
add a comment |
Here is the entry for thalidomide in Merriam-Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1983):
thalidomide n {phthalic acid + -id- (fr. imide) + -o- + imide} (1962) : a sedative and hypnotic drug C13H10N2O4 that has been the cause of malformation of infants born to mothers using it during pregnancy
What this entry means is that thalidomide is a generic name for a chemical compound—like aspirin. It isn't a proper name and therefore should not be capitalized.
According to the Wikipedia article on thalidomide, the drug was sold under the following trade names:
Contergan, Thalomid, Immunoprin, Talidex, Talizer, Neurosedyn, Distaval and many others
But if you use the generic term thalidomide, you aren't pointing to any specific brand sold during the 1950s (or later) and, again, you shouldn't capitalize the word.
Here is the entry for thalidomide in Merriam-Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1983):
thalidomide n {phthalic acid + -id- (fr. imide) + -o- + imide} (1962) : a sedative and hypnotic drug C13H10N2O4 that has been the cause of malformation of infants born to mothers using it during pregnancy
What this entry means is that thalidomide is a generic name for a chemical compound—like aspirin. It isn't a proper name and therefore should not be capitalized.
According to the Wikipedia article on thalidomide, the drug was sold under the following trade names:
Contergan, Thalomid, Immunoprin, Talidex, Talizer, Neurosedyn, Distaval and many others
But if you use the generic term thalidomide, you aren't pointing to any specific brand sold during the 1950s (or later) and, again, you shouldn't capitalize the word.
answered Mar 21 at 1:48
Sven YargsSven Yargs
37634
37634
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
add a comment |
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
3
3
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
although, interestingly enough, the word aspirin was trademarked by Bayer in Canada and is not a generic term there. Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) is the generic term in all countries.
– Lauren Ipsum
Mar 21 at 10:05
1
1
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
"Heroin" is a trademarked term. So if you ask a drug dealer for "Heroin", you're breaking the law!
– Acccumulation
Mar 21 at 17:10
1
1
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
@LaurenIpsum Wikipedia lists "Bayer Aspirin" as trademark but "aspirin" as USAN which essential means the name is public domain in the US. But I'm not sure if that's also true internationally, so I agree that acetylsalicylic acid would have been a better example.
– kapex
Mar 21 at 20:13
add a comment |
The other answers correctly point out that "thalidomide" is a generic drug and is not trademarked. But I'd like to answer the more general question, which is if/how you can refer to a trademark in a work of fiction.
In a website article, Using Trademarks in Fiction, the author describes 3 issues to consider: “product disparagement,” “trademark dilution” and “trademark tarnishment.”
Product disparagement would be the main issue in your work. Technically it's only a problem if your claims are false, but we know that large companies will bring suit anyway if they feel the need. The costs for them in a garbage suit are few but they can control the press and bankrupt the writer. In the US, it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you can pay your lawyers.
In another web article, Can I Mention Brand Name Products in My Fiction?, the author focuses on 4 issues: "trademark infringement," "trademark dilution," "trademark tarnishment,"and "defamation."
Here, we also have recommendations of an abundance of caution. Big companies can be really touchy.
For example, the director Danny Boyle, told the press that he caused
Mercedes Benz logos to be digitally removed from cars in his film Slum
Dog Millionaire when the manufacturer objected to the depiction of its
cars in Bombay slum settings.
Makers of movies and TV shows generally are a lot more careful than book publishers, because of the wider audiences and more obvious references.
I have not found legal references for what to do when a product is widely acknowledged as having caused harm. Certainly it is okay to talk about (or even show explicitly) the dangers of cigarettes or lead. These aren't trademarks but they both have powerful lobbyists and industry groups. Remember how the beef industry went after Oprah for talking about mad cow disease on her show in 1996? She ultimately won, but only after a lot of her time and money.
So it depends. If all you're doing is mentioning that a character has a disability caused by thalidomide, even if it were a trademarked product, you're probably fine, as it is well-documented that these cases happened.
add a comment |
The other answers correctly point out that "thalidomide" is a generic drug and is not trademarked. But I'd like to answer the more general question, which is if/how you can refer to a trademark in a work of fiction.
In a website article, Using Trademarks in Fiction, the author describes 3 issues to consider: “product disparagement,” “trademark dilution” and “trademark tarnishment.”
Product disparagement would be the main issue in your work. Technically it's only a problem if your claims are false, but we know that large companies will bring suit anyway if they feel the need. The costs for them in a garbage suit are few but they can control the press and bankrupt the writer. In the US, it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you can pay your lawyers.
In another web article, Can I Mention Brand Name Products in My Fiction?, the author focuses on 4 issues: "trademark infringement," "trademark dilution," "trademark tarnishment,"and "defamation."
Here, we also have recommendations of an abundance of caution. Big companies can be really touchy.
For example, the director Danny Boyle, told the press that he caused
Mercedes Benz logos to be digitally removed from cars in his film Slum
Dog Millionaire when the manufacturer objected to the depiction of its
cars in Bombay slum settings.
Makers of movies and TV shows generally are a lot more careful than book publishers, because of the wider audiences and more obvious references.
I have not found legal references for what to do when a product is widely acknowledged as having caused harm. Certainly it is okay to talk about (or even show explicitly) the dangers of cigarettes or lead. These aren't trademarks but they both have powerful lobbyists and industry groups. Remember how the beef industry went after Oprah for talking about mad cow disease on her show in 1996? She ultimately won, but only after a lot of her time and money.
So it depends. If all you're doing is mentioning that a character has a disability caused by thalidomide, even if it were a trademarked product, you're probably fine, as it is well-documented that these cases happened.
add a comment |
The other answers correctly point out that "thalidomide" is a generic drug and is not trademarked. But I'd like to answer the more general question, which is if/how you can refer to a trademark in a work of fiction.
In a website article, Using Trademarks in Fiction, the author describes 3 issues to consider: “product disparagement,” “trademark dilution” and “trademark tarnishment.”
Product disparagement would be the main issue in your work. Technically it's only a problem if your claims are false, but we know that large companies will bring suit anyway if they feel the need. The costs for them in a garbage suit are few but they can control the press and bankrupt the writer. In the US, it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you can pay your lawyers.
In another web article, Can I Mention Brand Name Products in My Fiction?, the author focuses on 4 issues: "trademark infringement," "trademark dilution," "trademark tarnishment,"and "defamation."
Here, we also have recommendations of an abundance of caution. Big companies can be really touchy.
For example, the director Danny Boyle, told the press that he caused
Mercedes Benz logos to be digitally removed from cars in his film Slum
Dog Millionaire when the manufacturer objected to the depiction of its
cars in Bombay slum settings.
Makers of movies and TV shows generally are a lot more careful than book publishers, because of the wider audiences and more obvious references.
I have not found legal references for what to do when a product is widely acknowledged as having caused harm. Certainly it is okay to talk about (or even show explicitly) the dangers of cigarettes or lead. These aren't trademarks but they both have powerful lobbyists and industry groups. Remember how the beef industry went after Oprah for talking about mad cow disease on her show in 1996? She ultimately won, but only after a lot of her time and money.
So it depends. If all you're doing is mentioning that a character has a disability caused by thalidomide, even if it were a trademarked product, you're probably fine, as it is well-documented that these cases happened.
The other answers correctly point out that "thalidomide" is a generic drug and is not trademarked. But I'd like to answer the more general question, which is if/how you can refer to a trademark in a work of fiction.
In a website article, Using Trademarks in Fiction, the author describes 3 issues to consider: “product disparagement,” “trademark dilution” and “trademark tarnishment.”
Product disparagement would be the main issue in your work. Technically it's only a problem if your claims are false, but we know that large companies will bring suit anyway if they feel the need. The costs for them in a garbage suit are few but they can control the press and bankrupt the writer. In the US, it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you can pay your lawyers.
In another web article, Can I Mention Brand Name Products in My Fiction?, the author focuses on 4 issues: "trademark infringement," "trademark dilution," "trademark tarnishment,"and "defamation."
Here, we also have recommendations of an abundance of caution. Big companies can be really touchy.
For example, the director Danny Boyle, told the press that he caused
Mercedes Benz logos to be digitally removed from cars in his film Slum
Dog Millionaire when the manufacturer objected to the depiction of its
cars in Bombay slum settings.
Makers of movies and TV shows generally are a lot more careful than book publishers, because of the wider audiences and more obvious references.
I have not found legal references for what to do when a product is widely acknowledged as having caused harm. Certainly it is okay to talk about (or even show explicitly) the dangers of cigarettes or lead. These aren't trademarks but they both have powerful lobbyists and industry groups. Remember how the beef industry went after Oprah for talking about mad cow disease on her show in 1996? She ultimately won, but only after a lot of her time and money.
So it depends. If all you're doing is mentioning that a character has a disability caused by thalidomide, even if it were a trademarked product, you're probably fine, as it is well-documented that these cases happened.
answered Mar 21 at 16:15
CynCyn
17.8k13883
17.8k13883
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thalidomide is the generic form of the brand-name drug Thalomid. I would think no one owns a trademark on a generic name. If you are taking thalidomide to treat XYZ, the most common side effects are: … is an example of a name that is geneticized but if the sentence reads; If you are taking Thalomid … then you would be using the brands name.
add a comment |
Thalidomide is the generic form of the brand-name drug Thalomid. I would think no one owns a trademark on a generic name. If you are taking thalidomide to treat XYZ, the most common side effects are: … is an example of a name that is geneticized but if the sentence reads; If you are taking Thalomid … then you would be using the brands name.
add a comment |
Thalidomide is the generic form of the brand-name drug Thalomid. I would think no one owns a trademark on a generic name. If you are taking thalidomide to treat XYZ, the most common side effects are: … is an example of a name that is geneticized but if the sentence reads; If you are taking Thalomid … then you would be using the brands name.
Thalidomide is the generic form of the brand-name drug Thalomid. I would think no one owns a trademark on a generic name. If you are taking thalidomide to treat XYZ, the most common side effects are: … is an example of a name that is geneticized but if the sentence reads; If you are taking Thalomid … then you would be using the brands name.
answered Mar 21 at 2:17
Vincent Wiley
add a comment |
add a comment |
If you have a character who has a birth defect caused by thalidomide, just use the term. Thalidomide child or thalidomide baby were how this defect was called.
When I was in university, one of the girls in our dorm announced that her younger sister would be joining her. She warned us of two things: Susan was a thalidomide child and DO NOT help her.
Susan moved into the dorm and she was a tough minded girl. In her case, her defect was that her arms were extremely short. Carrying books was difficult for her, but we had been instructed on how not to drive her nuts.
One afternoon, I saw Susan by the elevator of the Humanities building and she had dropped her books. I asked her if she would like some help - an important lesson in respect - and she agreed it would be faster if I helped, so let me pick up a few of her books and give them to her.
Susan once told me that the doctor who prescribed the thalidomide to her mother apologized to her.
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
add a comment |
If you have a character who has a birth defect caused by thalidomide, just use the term. Thalidomide child or thalidomide baby were how this defect was called.
When I was in university, one of the girls in our dorm announced that her younger sister would be joining her. She warned us of two things: Susan was a thalidomide child and DO NOT help her.
Susan moved into the dorm and she was a tough minded girl. In her case, her defect was that her arms were extremely short. Carrying books was difficult for her, but we had been instructed on how not to drive her nuts.
One afternoon, I saw Susan by the elevator of the Humanities building and she had dropped her books. I asked her if she would like some help - an important lesson in respect - and she agreed it would be faster if I helped, so let me pick up a few of her books and give them to her.
Susan once told me that the doctor who prescribed the thalidomide to her mother apologized to her.
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
add a comment |
If you have a character who has a birth defect caused by thalidomide, just use the term. Thalidomide child or thalidomide baby were how this defect was called.
When I was in university, one of the girls in our dorm announced that her younger sister would be joining her. She warned us of two things: Susan was a thalidomide child and DO NOT help her.
Susan moved into the dorm and she was a tough minded girl. In her case, her defect was that her arms were extremely short. Carrying books was difficult for her, but we had been instructed on how not to drive her nuts.
One afternoon, I saw Susan by the elevator of the Humanities building and she had dropped her books. I asked her if she would like some help - an important lesson in respect - and she agreed it would be faster if I helped, so let me pick up a few of her books and give them to her.
Susan once told me that the doctor who prescribed the thalidomide to her mother apologized to her.
If you have a character who has a birth defect caused by thalidomide, just use the term. Thalidomide child or thalidomide baby were how this defect was called.
When I was in university, one of the girls in our dorm announced that her younger sister would be joining her. She warned us of two things: Susan was a thalidomide child and DO NOT help her.
Susan moved into the dorm and she was a tough minded girl. In her case, her defect was that her arms were extremely short. Carrying books was difficult for her, but we had been instructed on how not to drive her nuts.
One afternoon, I saw Susan by the elevator of the Humanities building and she had dropped her books. I asked her if she would like some help - an important lesson in respect - and she agreed it would be faster if I helped, so let me pick up a few of her books and give them to her.
Susan once told me that the doctor who prescribed the thalidomide to her mother apologized to her.
edited Mar 21 at 14:58
Glorfindel
131119
131119
answered Mar 21 at 14:34
RasdashanRasdashan
9,75311160
9,75311160
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
add a comment |
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
I approved the edit but this is not a sample of fiction.
– Rasdashan
Mar 21 at 15:01
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Writing Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f43844%2fhow-can-i-safely-use-thalidomide-in-my-novel-while-respecting-the-trademark%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
perhaps the name is used widely enough that it can pass as a generic term, like ziploc bag or garbage disposall
– jlovegren
Mar 20 at 22:57
5
BTW, thalidomide is not the trade name, it is the generic. And the disaster it was is commonly known. I can’t see how it would hurt the company to “reveal” that because for a patient to use it 1. They have something severe and 2. They can only get it through a special program and have to sign all sorts of stuff and be on 2 forms of birth control, etc. So you would not be defaming it in anyway. (I am not a lawyer or author.). Good luck on Writing SE. i lurk there sometimes. I dkn’t write but it is interesting to see what writers need to thibk about.
– Damila
Mar 21 at 1:49
1
Just in case this wasn’t clear, trademark fundamentally doesn’t mean that you’re not allowed to use the trademarked term. There are specific restrictions but those don’t prevent you from general usage. In practice, care is obviously still advisable.
– Konrad Rudolph
Mar 21 at 17:15
2
Trademarks do not prevent you from talking about something. I can refer to a car as a Ford Mustang in a story (and even have it break down and cause 20 deaths) without any consequence. What I cannot do is create a vehicle and call it a Ford Mustang.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:36
1
If you are worried about libel laws, they have to prove malice. Just look up the movie Absence of Malice for a crash course in that bit of law.
– ShadoCat
Mar 21 at 17:37